"What moron would shoot themselves in the head by doing that?" - CoStar Boss Andy Florance Denies Involvement in Commissions Trials

November 17, 2023
Share this Post: 

CoStar CEO Andy Florance says that his company has nothing to do with the ongoing bombshell buyer-side commissions trials currently rocking the U.S. real estate industry.

Asked about his company's possible involvement in the suits by HousingWire at the National Association of Realtors NXT convention in Anaheim, the longtime boss of the Washington-based data giant was effusive in his denial.

“We had zero involvement with that lawsuit. We learned about it from NAR long after it started.”

“We have 189,000 real estate clients who work with us. What moron would shoot themselves in the head by doing that? We had nothing to do with it at all, period. Anyone who says we were funding that is lying. As a public company, we’re a pretty open book.”

Several trials around buyer-side commissions threaten to fundamentally change the U.S. real estate industry and CoStar could perhaps be the biggest beneficiary.

At the end of November, the share prices of real estate portal operators Zillow and Redfin along with the prices of several major brokerages took a big hit as a Kansas City jury ruled that the NAR, HomeServicesofAmerica and Keller Willams were guilty of colluding to fix the commission paid to buyers' agents. CoStar's share price shot up.

In contrast to most markets around the world, for most U.S. property transactions both the seller and the buyer are represented by a real estate agent. Typically the two agents split the commission which is often between five and six percent of the value of the home with the home seller responsible for paying both agents.

The National Association of Realtors (NAR) has a rule that requires all brokers to offer buyer-broker compensation when listing a property on an MLS. The suit claimed this has driven up costs to the seller and stifled competition.

Although there has been talk of an appeal against the Kansas City ruling (known as the Sitzer|Burnett case) there are now several other similar cases being brought against the NAR all while the agent association is going through leadership change.

It's not just the agent association and its members that are at risk from the upshot of any court case. Leading U.S. real estate portal Zillow could see its business model come under significant pressure if a ruling leads to government legislation restricting or banning buyer agent commissions.

Zillow's main Premier Agent product, which generates a very substantial percentage of the Seattle-based company's revenue, sees buyers' agents pay the portal for leads. On the other hand, CoStar's portal Homes.com primarily monetises listings in a similar way to portals in the rest of the world by charging listings agents for increased visibility on its results pages.

The fact that Homes.com's business model would not be affected by any ruling while its main rival's might well be was enough for HousingWire's journalist to at least put the question to Andy Florance.

November 17, 2023
Edmund got to know the world of portals and marketplaces working at Mitula Group (which became Lifull Connect after the buyout in 2018). He worked directly with hundreds of portals across the world in his role in the content department for three and a half years before transferring to the SEO department to understand the inner workings of listings sites. He joined Online Marketplaces as Head of Content in March 2020.

Subscribe to our mailing list to get the famous, free Friday newsletter!

News and analysis to help build better online marketplace businesses, in your inbox, every Friday

Related News

Shutterstock 1892686795 1
Will There Be Any Agent-Controlled Property Portals Left in Ten Years?

"Wow. Agents really missed the boat, didn't they?" That was my reaction when I first plotted the graphs for our...

Read More
Propertyguru Appoints Ray Ferguson as New Chairman of the Board

PropertyGuru, Southeast Asia’s leading PropTech company, has appointed Ray Ferguson as the new Chairman of the Board, effective January 2024....

Read More
Shutterstock 1318716863
U.S. Rentals Marketplace Dwellsy Bags $11.5 Million Seed Round

The U.S. rentals marketplace site operator Dwellsy has announced that it has raised a seed round worth $11.5 million led...

Read More
Offerpad Extended Stay
Offerpad Reports Increased Gross Profits But Reduced Revenues in Q3 Financial Results

US iBuyer Offerpad says it achieved higher gross profits year-on-year (YoY) despite falling revenues in its Q3 results—with a slight...

Read More

Editor's Pick